找回密碼
 To register

QQ登錄

只需一步,快速開始

掃一掃,訪問微社區(qū)

打印 上一主題 下一主題

Titlebook: Decapitation in Sources on Alexander the Great; Marc Mendoza Book 2023 The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s), under exclusive li

[復(fù)制鏈接]
樓主: oxidation
21#
發(fā)表于 2025-3-25 07:14:31 | 只看該作者
Greeks, Romans, and Decapitations, taboo and it was strongly despised as a barbarous and hubristic practice, in Rome it was often related to heroic national deeds and it was a prominent feature in Roman warfare ideology. This difference becomes a key aspect to explain the misbalance observed among Alexander’s sources. However, in th
22#
發(fā)表于 2025-3-25 08:12:31 | 只看該作者
Non-Curtian Decapitations, first one, that of Ariobarzanes’ beheading, is only described by Plutarch, who took the information from a certain Aretades. However, there are several aspects that make this story extremely dubious and should be probably discarded. The second episode, relating to the decapitation of a sailor by Al
23#
發(fā)表于 2025-3-25 14:10:39 | 只看該作者
Negotiating Heads,gotiations. There are different versions of the first one, but in the case of Curtius, some influence from Livy’s and Polybius’ accounts of Chiomara’s story can be reasonably argued. In the second case, some differences between Curtius’ version and the rest of the traditions can reflect some reworki
24#
發(fā)表于 2025-3-25 17:03:26 | 只看該作者
Punished Heads,apitation of Macedonian Parmenio’s corpse. Again, both instances are only found in Curtius, and the second one is especially problematic. It took place in a very troubled period for Alexander, and such an outrage would have surely found its way in the rest of the tradition. However, both stories see
25#
發(fā)表于 2025-3-25 20:20:06 | 只看該作者
26#
發(fā)表于 2025-3-26 03:24:20 | 只看該作者
Conclusions,sources. Even the handful not found in Curtius’ book coincide with . in it and, in consequence, it cannot be ruled out that he had actually included them as well. Besides, the two non-Curtian decapitations, as shown, come from unreliable sources, and their historicity is very dubious.
27#
發(fā)表于 2025-3-26 06:14:44 | 只看該作者
tors at work in ancient historiography.Compares and contrast.This book explores cases of decapitation found in sources on the reign of Alexander the Great. Despite the enormous literature on the career of Alexander the Great, this is the first study on the characterisation of violent deaths during h
28#
發(fā)表于 2025-3-26 11:00:58 | 只看該作者
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-658-10013-1al aspects that make this story extremely dubious and should be probably discarded. The second episode, relating to the decapitation of a sailor by Alexander, is found in several authors, but again the episode appears very dubious. The versions are contradicting and perhaps the story was shaped after a similar episode by Xerxes.
29#
發(fā)表于 2025-3-26 15:45:24 | 只看該作者
30#
發(fā)表于 2025-3-26 20:33:04 | 只看該作者
Das Politische System der Europ?ischen Unionon of single combats, and some literary parallelisms can be tracked down (especially from Livy). In this kind of episodes, decapitation was typically the ‘right’ closing of the story, an aspect that Curtius included as well.
 關(guān)于派博傳思  派博傳思旗下網(wǎng)站  友情鏈接
派博傳思介紹 公司地理位置 論文服務(wù)流程 影響因子官網(wǎng) 吾愛論文網(wǎng) 大講堂 北京大學(xué) Oxford Uni. Harvard Uni.
發(fā)展歷史沿革 期刊點評 投稿經(jīng)驗總結(jié) SCIENCEGARD IMPACTFACTOR 派博系數(shù) 清華大學(xué) Yale Uni. Stanford Uni.
QQ|Archiver|手機(jī)版|小黑屋| 派博傳思國際 ( 京公網(wǎng)安備110108008328) GMT+8, 2025-10-11 16:46
Copyright © 2001-2015 派博傳思   京公網(wǎng)安備110108008328 版權(quán)所有 All rights reserved
快速回復(fù) 返回頂部 返回列表
禹城市| 景谷| 辽宁省| 都昌县| 襄汾县| 资兴市| 秦安县| 阿巴嘎旗| 衡阳县| 富平县| 宿松县| 辽中县| 平顺县| 图片| 曲沃县| 桐梓县| 安乡县| 永丰县| 来安县| 石家庄市| 长宁区| 金平| 宁国市| 绥芬河市| 商都县| 禄丰县| 安阳县| 道真| 临高县| 香河县| 孟津县| 乌什县| 湘潭县| 泾源县| 汝阳县| 灌云县| 玉环县| 克东县| 阳新县| 龙州县| 盐源县|